
  Using physical DMA provided by OHCI-1394 FireWire controllers for debugging
  ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Introduction
------------

Basically all FireWire controllers which are in use today are compliant
to the OHCI-1394 specification which defines the controller to be a PCI
bus master which uses DMA to offload data transfers from the CPU and has
a "Physical Response Unit" which executes specific requests by employing
PCI-Bus master DMA after applying filters defined by the OHCI-1394 driver.

Once properly configured, remote machines can send these requests to
ask the OHCI-1394 controller to perform read and write requests on
physical system memory and, for read requests, send the result of
the physical memory read back to the requester.

With that, it is possible to debug issues by reading interesting memory
locations such as buffers like the printk buffer or the process table.

Retrieving a full system memory dump is also possible over the FireWire,
using data transfer rates in the order of 10MB/s or more.

With most FireWire controllers, memory access is limited to the low 4 GB
of physical address space.  This can be a problem on IA64 machines where
memory is located mostly above that limit, but it is rarely a problem on
more common hardware such as x86, x86-64 and PowerPC.

At least LSI FW643e and FW643e2 controllers are known to support access to
physical addresses above 4 GB, but this feature is currently not enabled by
Linux.

Together with a early initialization of the OHCI-1394 controller for debugging,
this facility proved most useful for examining long debugs logs in the printk
buffer on to debug early boot problems in areas like ACPI where the system
fails to boot and other means for debugging (serial port) are either not
available (notebooks) or too slow for extensive debug information (like ACPI).

Drivers
-------

The firewire-ohci driver in drivers/firewire uses filtered physical
DMA by default, which is more secure but not suitable for remote debugging.
Pass the remote_dma=1 parameter to the driver to get unfiltered physical DMA.

Because the firewire-ohci driver depends on the PCI enumeration to be
completed, an initialization routine which runs pretty early has been
implemented for x86.  This routine runs long before console_init() can be
called, i.e. before the printk buffer appears on the console.

To activate it, enable CONFIG_PROVIDE_OHCI1394_DMA_INIT (Kernel hacking menu:
Remote debugging over FireWire early on boot) and pass the parameter
"ohci1394_dma=early" to the recompiled kernel on boot.

Tools
-----

firescope - Originally developed by Benjamin Herrenschmidt, Andi Kleen ported
it from PowerPC to x86 and x86_64 and added functionality, firescope can now
be used to view the printk buffer of a remote machine, even with live update.

Bernhard Kaindl enhanced firescope to support accessing 64-bit machines
from 32-bit firescope and vice versa:
- http://v3.sk/~lkundrak/firescope/

and he implemented fast system dump (alpha version - read README.txt):
- http://halobates.de/firewire/firedump-0.1.tar.bz2

There is also a gdb proxy for firewire which allows to use gdb to access
data which can be referenced from symbols found by gdb in vmlinux:
- http://halobates.de/firewire/fireproxy-0.33.tar.bz2

The latest version of this gdb proxy (fireproxy-0.34) can communicate (not
yet stable) with kgdb over an memory-based communication module (kgdbom).

Getting Started
---------------

The OHCI-1394 specification regulates that the OHCI-1394 controller must
disable all physical DMA on each bus reset.

This means that if you want to debug an issue in a system state where
interrupts are disabled and where no polling of the OHCI-1394 controller
for bus resets takes place, you have to establish any FireWire cable
connections and fully initialize all FireWire hardware __before__ the
system enters such state.

Step-by-step instructions for using firescope with early OHCI initialization:

1) Verify that your hardware is supported:

   Load the firewire-ohci module and check your kernel logs.
   You should see a line similar to

   firewire_ohci 0000:15:00.1: added OHCI v1.0 device as card 2, 4 IR + 4 IT
   ... contexts, quirks 0x11

   when loading the driver. If you have no supported controller, many PCI,
   CardBus and even some Express cards which are fully compliant to OHCI-1394
   specification are available. If it requires no driver for Windows operating
   systems, it most likely is. Only specialized shops have cards which are not
   compliant, they are based on TI PCILynx chips and require drivers for Windows
   operating systems.

   The mentioned kernel log message contains the string "physUB" if the
   controller implements a writable Physical Upper Bound register.  This is
   required for physical DMA above 4 GB (but not utilized by Linux yet).

2) Establish a working FireWire cable connection:

   Any FireWire cable, as long at it provides electrically and mechanically
   stable connection and has matching connectors (there are small 4-pin and
   large 6-pin FireWire ports) will do.

   If an driver is running on both machines you should see a line like

   firewire_core 0000:15:00.1: created device fw1: GUID 00061b0020105917, S400

   on both machines in the kernel log when the cable is plugged in
   and connects the two machines.

3) Test physical DMA using firescope:

   On the debug host, make sure that /dev/fw* is accessible,
   then start firescope:

	$ firescope
	Port 0 (/dev/fw1) opened, 2 nodes detected

	FireScope
	---------
	Target : <unspecified>
	Gen    : 1
	[Ctrl-T] choose target
	[Ctrl-H] this menu
	[Ctrl-Q] quit

    ------> Press Ctrl-T now, the output should be similar to:

	2 nodes available, local node is: 0
	 0: ffc0, uuid: 00000000 00000000 [LOCAL]
	 1: ffc1, uuid: 00279000 ba4bb801

   Besides the [LOCAL] node, it must show another node without error message.

4) Prepare for debugging with early OHCI-1394 initialization:

   4.1) Kernel compilation and installation on debug target

   Compile the kernel to be debugged with CONFIG_PROVIDE_OHCI1394_DMA_INIT
   (Kernel hacking: Provide code for enabling DMA over FireWire early on boot)
   enabled and install it on the machine to be debugged (debug target).

   4.2) Transfer the System.map of the debugged kernel to the debug host

   Copy the System.map of the kernel be debugged to the debug host (the host
   which is connected to the debugged machine over the FireWire cable).

5) Retrieving the printk buffer contents:

   With the FireWire cable connected, the OHCI-1394 driver on the debugging
   host loaded, reboot the debugged machine, booting the kernel which has
   CONFIG_PROVIDE_OHCI1394_DMA_INIT enabled, with the option ohci1394_dma=early.

   Then, on the debugging host, run firescope, for example by using -A:

	firescope -A System.map-of-debug-target-kernel

   Note: -A automatically attaches to the first non-local node. It only works
   reliably if only connected two machines are connected using FireWire.

   After having attached to the debug target, press Ctrl-D to view the
   complete printk buffer or Ctrl-U to enter auto update mode and get an
   updated live view of recent kernel messages logged on the debug target.

   Call "firescope -h" to get more information on firescope's options.

Notes
-----
Documentation and specifications: http://halobates.de/firewire/

FireWire is a trademark of Apple Inc. - for more information please refer to:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FireWire